Findings of Red Meat Study Called into Question
NCI study says there is link between red meat and mortality.
Compiled by staff
Published: Mar 25, 2009
A study conducted by the National Cancer Institute claims that there is a link between red meat consumption and death. The 10 year study of more than half-a-million middle-aged and elderly Americans found a 30% higher death rate from daily consumption of beef, pork and processed meats. Cancer-causing compounds, too much iron, especially in pork, and saturated fat are all blamed for the linkage. In contrast, the study concluded that consumption of fish, chicken, turkey and other poultry decreased the risk of death by a small amount.
The American Meat Institute, National Cattlemen's Beef Association, National Pork Board and USDA were quick to call into question the results of the study. AMI Executive Vice President James Hodges says the findings were based on unreliable self-reporting by the study participants and NCBA Human Nutrition Director Shalene McNeill says other factors complicated the study.
"Those with increased risk also were two to three times more likely to smoke, they had under-consumption of fruits and vegetables and they were more likely to be overweight," McNeill said. "So there were a lot of unhealthy behaviors that complicate the findings in this study.
National Pork Board Dietician Ceci Snyder says the study shows a little bit of ignorance in claiming that pork has excessive iron content.
"The iron in chicken and pork is almost identical," Snyder said. "Someone hasn't really looked into the composition data to show that, so that's an argument that shows that they really don't know the facts about meat."
Permalink: Click here
Tagged: usda, National Cattlemen's Beef Association, NCBA
|